Choosing Exterior Doors – The Case for Wood Over Fiberglass

Exterior Doors

Your home’s exterior creates a lasting first impression, and the front door plays a pivotal role in this. Selecting the right material for your front door is essential—it needs to not only enhance your home’s curb appeal but also endure the elements.

The ideal material for an exterior door should offer both aesthetic appeal and durability, as well as the versatility to be tailored to your preferred size, shape, style, and finish.

So, which material should you choose: wood or fiberglass?

There’s plenty of debate and mixed information regarding the benefits and drawbacks of wood versus fiberglass doors. Our goal is to clarify these differences, helping you make a well-informed decision.

Dreaming of new interior doors that will add elegance to your home? Visit the IndigoDoors online store, where quality doors are available at great prices with fast delivery.

The Unmatched Design Flexibility of Wood

Wood exterior doors offer a level of versatility that fiberglass simply cannot match. These doors can be customized to virtually any size, shape, or thickness to meet your specific needs. The placement of stiles and rails can be adjusted to your preferences, allowing for creative modifications like arch tops, clipped corners, or even Dutch doors.

In contrast, fiberglass doors are produced from molds that are used to create thousands of identical replicas, limiting their customizability.

Wood doors’ exceptional customization options allow you to incorporate eye-catching trends into your home’s entrance, such as:

  • Dutch Doors
    These charming doors add a unique, classic appeal while allowing for flexible ventilation options.
  • Monster XL Doors
    Oversized doors make a grand statement, providing both an impressive visual impact and practical functionality.
  • Natural Wood Doors
    The beauty of natural wood grain enhances your home’s aesthetic, offering a warm, inviting look that can be stained or finished to your liking.

Wood Exterior Doors: Authentic Elegance

Wood exterior doors exude an unparalleled high-end appearance and warmth because they are genuine. The authenticity of solid-wood doors is almost impossible to replicate. While fiberglass door manufacturers strive to mimic the look of natural wood, there’s a clear distinction between the authentic and the artificial.

At a fundamental level, fiberglass lacks the intrinsic look and feel of natural wood. It cannot replicate the unique grain patterns or the rich, earthy tones that make each wood door distinct.

Fiberglass doors with a wood-grain appearance often feature repetitive, stamped patterns that lack the individuality and character of real wood.

“It’s easy to understand why many of us still like our doors to be made of wood,” notes a home improvement expert at This Old House magazine. “Nothing else matches the material’s warmth and satisfying heft.”

Natural Insulation and Precise Fit of Wood Doors

Wood exterior doors offer natural insulation properties that contribute to maintaining stable temperatures inside your home. Although fiberglass doors are known for their insulating qualities, achieved by filling the hollow cavity with insulating foam, wood inherently provides effective insulation.

The most significant factor affecting your home’s temperature with exterior doors is how well the door is fitted and hung within its frame.

Wood’s customizability allows for a precise fit in virtually any size and shape, ensuring a snug installation that minimizes gaps. This tight fit helps prevent heat from entering or escaping, enhancing your home’s energy efficiency.

High-Quality Exterior Wood Doors

All exterior building products, including both fiberglass and wood doors, require some level of maintenance. The maintenance demands depend largely on the door’s exposure to weather and the sun’s UV rays.

Thanks to modern construction techniques, today’s exterior wood doors are designed to maintain their beauty and functionality in a variety of climates and weather conditions.

If a door is shielded by a porch or overhang, almost any type of door can be used. However, for doors with no overhang protection, selecting the appropriate product upgrades is crucial to ensure durability.

When discussing weather-resistant exterior doors, Simpson Door Company’s IndigoDoors are a standout choice. These doors, which come with a 10-year warranty even without a porch or overhang, feature a modified mortise-and-tenon construction technique and use weather-resistant wood species such as Douglas Fir, Sapele Mahogany, Nootka Cypress, and Western Hemlock.

This combination ensures that the door retains its robust beauty and functionality for years, regardless of the weather conditions it faces.

Like it? Share with your friends!